Grilled Cheese
AmericanThe grilled cheese sandwich is two slices of bread, buttered on the outside and filled with cheese, then toasted in a skillet until the bread turns golden-brown and the cheese melts into a stretchy, gooey interior. It is one of the simplest and most universally loved comfort foods in America, as at home in a five-year-old's lunchbox as it is on an upscale bistro menu.
What Is Grilled Cheese?
Open-faced cheese toasts date back to ancient Roman times, but the modern closed grilled cheese sandwich became a staple in the United States during the 1920s and 1930s. The convergence of affordable sliced bread (introduced by Wonder Bread in 1928), processed American cheese (patented by James L. Kraft in 1916), and the economic constraints of the Great Depression made the grilled cheese sandwich a practical, inexpensive meal. The U.S. Navy served open-faced "American cheese filling sandwiches" to sailors during World War II, further cementing the dish in national food culture. By the 1960s, the closed, griddled version with two slices of bread had become the standard. The sandwich experienced a gourmet revival in the 2000s and 2010s, with restaurants like Melt Bar & Grilled in Cleveland and The American Grilled Cheese Kitchen in San Francisco elevating the format with artisanal cheeses, sourdough bread, and additions like caramelized onions, bacon, and truffle oil.
What Does Grilled Cheese Taste Like?
The exterior crunch of properly toasted, butter-crisped bread gives way immediately to the soft, molten cheese inside. American cheese delivers a mild, creamy, salty flavor with a smooth, almost sauce-like melt. Sharp cheddar adds more tang and a slightly grainy texture. Gruyere brings a nutty sweetness. The butter on the bread caramelizes during cooking, adding a rich, toasty flavor that plain toast cannot achieve. When paired with tomato soup, the acidic, sweet warmth of the soup and the salty, fatty crunch of the sandwich create a contrast that has become one of America's most iconic food pairings.
Key Ingredients
- Bread -- white sandwich bread is traditional; sourdough adds tang and sturdier structure for gourmet versions.
- Cheese -- American cheese for the smoothest melt; sharp cheddar for more flavor; a blend of both is a popular compromise.
- Butter -- applied generously to the outside of each bread slice before griddling; some cooks use mayonnaise instead for an even crispier crust.
- Optional additions -- tomato slices, caramelized onions, crispy bacon, sliced pickles, or a smear of Dijon mustard for enhanced versions.
How Grilled Cheese Is Traditionally Served
A grilled cheese is served hot from the skillet, typically sliced diagonally to reveal the molten cheese stretching between the two halves. In diners and cafes, it arrives on a simple plate alongside a bowl of tomato soup for dipping, a handful of potato chips, or a pickle spear. It is a handheld food, eaten immediately while the cheese is still melted. The sandwich cools and stiffens quickly, so speed matters.
Ordering Tips for First-Timers
Ask what cheese the kitchen uses. If it is only American singles, the sandwich will be mild and creamy but one-dimensional. A blend of American (for melt) and cheddar (for flavor) is the sweet spot. Request the bread toasted on medium heat rather than high -- rushing the process browns the outside before the cheese melts through. If the menu offers a grilled cheese upgrade with add-ons, bacon and caramelized onions are the two best additions because they add salt, sweetness, and texture without overwhelming the cheese.
Grilled Cheese vs Similar Dishes
A grilled cheese differs from a quesadilla in that it uses sliced bread rather than a tortilla, and the cheese selection is different (American/cheddar vs. Oaxaca/Monterey Jack). A croque monsieur is the French cousin: it adds ham and bechamel sauce, making it richer and more substantial. A cheese toastie in Britain and Australia is essentially the same sandwich but often made in a sandwich press rather than a skillet, giving it a different crust pattern. A patty melt combines a grilled cheese with a hamburger patty, bridging the gap between sandwich and burger.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best cheese for grilled cheese?
A 50/50 blend of American cheese and sharp cheddar gives you the best of both: American melts smoothly and holds the sandwich together, while cheddar adds actual flavor depth. Fontina and Gruyere are excellent upscale alternatives with nutty, complex flavors and good melting properties.
Should I use butter or mayo on grilled cheese?
Butter gives a rich, toasty flavor and golden color. Mayonnaise spreads more evenly, browns more uniformly, and creates a slightly crispier crust because of its egg and oil content. Both work well. Many grilled cheese enthusiasts use mayo on the bread and butter in the pan.
Can I make grilled cheese in a toaster?
Toaster bags exist for this purpose, but the result lacks the buttery crust of a skillet-made sandwich. An oven broiler works as a backup: toast the bread open-faced with cheese on top until bubbly, then close the sandwich. A cast iron skillet over medium-low heat remains the best method for even browning and complete cheese melt.
Is grilled cheese a healthy meal?
A basic grilled cheese made with two slices of white bread, a tablespoon of butter, and two slices of American cheese contains roughly 350-400 calories. It is high in saturated fat and sodium but provides calcium and protein from the cheese. Using whole-grain bread and adding tomato slices increases the nutritional value.
Why is grilled cheese paired with tomato soup?
The pairing became standard during the Great Depression and World War II when both items were cheap and shelf-stable. Nutritionally and flavor-wise, the acidic, sweet soup cuts through the rich, fatty sandwich. The combination provides a complete meal of carbohydrates, fat, protein, and vegetables for very little cost.
Pairs Well With
If you enjoy Grilled Cheese, you might also like:
Want a random American dish?
Spin the Food Roulette and discover your next meal.
Spin American Roulette →